Feature: A View from the Id

Precious Knowledge Looks at Education Controversy in Arizona

Author: Bob Etier
Published: May 16, 2012 at 5:25 pm

What would you do if your city school system offered a program targeted at a segment of the student population and the program was remarkably successful, raising graduation rates in that group from 52% to 93% and increasing standardized test scores? In a perfect world, the teachers and administrators would be honored for their contribution not only to those students but also to the community which benefits from that success.  Alas, Arizona is not a perfect world. Despite Tucson Unified School District offering an effective program that has been copied by other districts throughout the nation, a bill was sponsored, passed, and signed by the governor ending Ethnic Studies programs but specifically aimed at  the Mexican­ American studies program offered in Tucson.

Filmmakers Ari Luis Palos and Eren Isabel McGinnis spent a year in high school classrooms “filming this innovative curriculum, documenting the transformative impact on students who became engaged, informed, and active in their communities.” The result is their documentary, Precious Knowledge, premiering on Independent Lens (PBS) on Thursday, May 17, 2012, at 10:00 p.m. (check local listings).




Precious Knowledge is a somewhat-biased look at the programs offered to Mexican American students and the efforts of legislators and state education authorities to ban them, seemingly based on one book  (The Pedagogy of the Oppressed by Paulo Freire) used in the curriculum. Only one of the critics expressing their fear of the seditious nature of the courses had spent any time observing any of the classes (his comments following his visit indicate he was less than open-minded about what he would witness). The critics’ arguments are weak, but apparently persuasive within the legislature, and no amount of protest by parents, teachers, and students could stem the tide of their movement.

Continued on the next page

About this article

Profile image for missbobetier

Article Author: Bob Etier

Two words describe Bob Etier: "female" and "weird." Like many freelance writers, there's something about her that isn't quite right. Read her stuff and find out what.

Bob Etier's author pageAuthor's Blog

Article Tags

Share: Bookmark and Share