28 blog reactions to http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2008/04/blogs-and-peer-review/

How to arrange for quality control in the project's next phase, however, is still something of an open question. Climate modeller and RealClimate blogger Gavin Schmidt (who's recently defended climate blogging in Nature Geoscience (subscription) and on RealClimate) told Inman* that generating respect for an open forum on climate "is by far the most challenging aspect of this proposal". Doubtless, many top climate scientists - who may at times volunteer half their workload toward the IPCC reports

where Gavin Schmidt's post about his Nature Geoscience view on how science blogs and traditional peer-review intersect has attracted more than 100 online comments from climate scientists and others. One commenter, "Tamino", writes: "Blogs don’t serve very well for communication among scientists. Peer review does more than just protect us from being inundated with substandard work; it protects authors from their own mistakes and improves the quality of what we write. Peer

Comment on Blogs and peer-review by Geoff Sherrington "Très toucher" et "Touche Atout" ULUSLARARASI AĞLAR Begich to officially enter race vs. Stevens Ресурсы по теме:Кто ходит в церковь? - Псковское Агентство Информации

Ссылки по теме: Comment on Blogs and peer-review by Ray Ladbury Presentación do libro “Buenos Aires gallega” Adobe to acquire Macromedia One Man is an island: Life of the Day Реально ли стать Геем? И как к этому относится?Корреспондент Донецка

http://www.xing.com/app/forum?op=showarticles;id=9194254;articleid=9356713#9356713′ alt=’Re^3: BB+Freisprecheinrichtung: Problem mit Autoherstellern …‘>Re^3: BB+Freisprecheinrichtung: Problem mit Autoherstellern … Comment on Blogs and peer-review by Don Worley Здесь много интересного:Апофеоз брендинга Новости Владивостока на VL.ruМорская пехота ТОФ на учениях выполнила поставленные перед ней

Comment on Blogs and peer-review by Don Worley Projekty adoptowalne, a Flex Chicago Recognize This Actor? President Is Boss, Clinton Says "Радио "Желтая Фейка" - это музыка вашего настроения. Каждому она напомнит что-тш свое,

Comment on Blogs and peer-review by Lynn Vincentnathan

post concerning the value of blogs and peer review received quite a few comments. A lot of those posts concerns something about climate physics, and I will not go into that because they confuse the hell out of a non-climate guy like me, but I found this particular comment by Myles Allen rather interesting: I personally would never comment critically in public on a peer-reviewed paper even to point out “obvious problems” (who is the judge of what is obvious here?) without at least exchanging e-mails with the authors to make sure I

gets some digs in at our exchanges. I'm sort of surprised he wants to bring it up again, but I guess he couldn't resist the chance for a few snide comments. Probably I would have done the same had the boot been on the other foot :-) Unfortunately one commentor on RC has already misinterpreted what he wrote. Where he says "needless to say, our response is not" [available to read as a rebuttal of the criticism], that should not be interpreted, as that reader did, to mean "our adversary is censoring our

Ссылки по теме: NetBeans IDE 6.1 Release Candidate Now Available! Comment on Blogs and peer-review by Ray Ladbury Здесь много интересного:Фотография обнаженной Карлы Бруни-Саркози будет продана с молотка - РИА Новости, Испанская пресса недовольна