Feature: Soapbox Musings

The Criticism Schism: The Worst Article A Commenter Could Read

Author: Bryan Cain-Jackson
Published: August 09, 2011 at 6:03 am
Share

Has anyone ever wondered about those overly judgmental people that pop up in the comments sections of an article or blog? Are you one of these annoying people that have yet to practice the art of constructive criticism? Stay tuned, we are about to take a small look at why you feel the need to pass judgment on people who do the things that you apparently are incapable of doing.

Critics and criticism are necessary animals and understandably so. There are critics that exist for nearly everything; they are often necessary in helping one make a major decision. What movie will my girlfriend and I go and see? What did the critics say about it? Am I going to buy the newest Chevy? Let me read the Consumer Reports to see what they had to say about it. Criticism, when constructive, informs us where we have failed and where we can improve in the future. For products like a Chevy, when the criticism is that the turning circle is far too wide hopefully Chevy will improve upon that in the future.

Critics are people who earn a living being experts in their fields. They know what makes these things tick, right? However, their insight is only the opinion of one. This is why there are so many critics because they will all each give us an alternative perspective.

Critics are respected and revered for their opinions and how they influence the decisions of others.

There is a very clear difference between that of a critic and a commenter who lacks constructive criticism skills.

The whole reason that there is a comment section is because most opinions are valued and intelligent discussions about the piece are encouraged; unfortunately people have abused this.

Continued on the next page
 
 

About this article

Profile image for makingsense

Article Author: Bryan Cain-Jackson

Bryan, an Assistant Editor for Technorati, is a native of the Northern California Bay Area and is an acclaimed actor/writer on the stage since the age of 12. His hobbies are winetasting, reading, writing, traveling, cooking, going to plays and watching a good film, particularly the classics. …

Bryan Cain-Jackson's author pageAuthor's Blog

Article Tags

Share: Bookmark and Share

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed
Please read our comment policy